.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

Friday, May 06, 2005

'Reverse incorporation' and Korematsu

A confab of bloggy law professors over at Volokh has gotten around to the question of "reverse incorporation," whereby the Supreme Court decided that, even though the equal protection clause explicitly applies only to the states, “it would be unthinkable that the same Constitution would impose a lesser duty on the Federal Government.” (Chief Justice Earl Warren writing for the majority in Bolling v. Sharpe, 347 U.S. 497, 500 (1954).) i.e. It is "unthinkable" that the Fourteenth Amendment means what it says, so Justice Warren was magnanimous enough to fix it for us!

Volokh contributor David Bernstein links a paper he has written arguing that Warren's main argument in Bolling actually has a sound Constitutional foundation and that the "reverse incorporation" pitch is just dicta. Be that as it may, Bolling is in any event not the case that established the reverse incorporation doctrine. That dishonor goes to United States v. Korematsu, the case that upheld the internment of Japanese-Americans during WWII. Where Bolling declared the principle of reverse incorporation without actually relying on it, Korematsu had ten years earlier relied on the principle of reverse incorporation without declaring it.

Korematsu's surreptitious approach to reverse incorporation actually turns out to have been much more harmful than the overt approach has ever been. The overt approach is overtly unconstitutional, which has limited its application. Korematsu, on the other hand, just happens to be the case that established the entire modern system for deciding when constitutional provisions can be over-ridden, and it established this system while carefully eliding all distinctions between state and federal government (so as to hide the fact that it was misapplying the Fourteenth Amendment to the federal government).

What is the consequence of eliding the distinction between state and federal interests? Just consider what the primary federal interest is: the Constitution. Korematsu's sneaky approach to reverse incorporation has had the effect of placing the Constitution on the same plane as generic state interests, effectively annihilating the principle of constitutional supremacy! This is why we now see such abominations as the Supreme Court in Grutter v. Bollinger acknowledging that racial preferences in state university admissions violates the equal protection clause, yet at the same time allowing the equal protection to give way on the strength of a highly dubious competing state interest: Michigan's claim that its law students get a better education when students of one race are favored over students of another race.

It is a borderline question whether this proclaimed state interest is even an admissible state interest under the Constitution. Certainly it is not constitutionally required. How then can it take precedence over an actual constitutional provision? Aren't constitutional provisions only to give way when they confront competing constitutional provisions? Not under Korematsu. ANY "compelling state interest," be be it a constitutional requirement, or a mere state level interest, is sufficient grounds, post-Korematsu for setting aside a constitutional provision. It is not a necessary grounds, but it IS sufficient. The Court gets to decide what it thinks is weightier: the proclaimed compelling-state-interest, or the Constitution. The very principle of constitutional supremacy is set aside.

In the Korematsu case, there actually WAS another constitutional provision on the other side of the federal-equal-protection-requirement that the Court wanted to fabricate. Opposing the supposed federal-equal-protection-rights of the interned Japanese were the Constitutionally granted war powers of the President, and Article I section 9 is explicit that war powers take precedence over individual rights: "The Privilege of the Writ of Habeas Corpus [i.e. the enforcement of individual rights] shall not be suspended, unless when in Cases of Rebellion or Invasion the public Safety may require it." [Article I section 9 is nominally addressing the war powers of Congress, but the same prioritization applies to the war powers of the executive, which is the final judge of military necessity.] The Court didn't have enough hubris to in time of war try to overturn the Constitution's explicit prioritization of war powers and so it made the correct ruling (upholding internment), but it did so on the wrong grounds.

To uphold the fiction that the federal government is constrained by the equal protection requirement, the Court had to elide the distinction between federal and state, ushering in the ultimate instrument of "living Constitution" jurisprudence. The Court can now set aside the Constitution in favor of absolutely whatever it deigns to designate a "compelling state interest," and not just in the area of equal protection law. This same criterion has migrated from equal protection to First Amendment law. That is how the Court (in McConnell v. FEC) was able to uphold the unlimited regulation of political speech under McCain-Feingold. It found a version of a compelling state interest in regulating political speech and this was sufficient for setting aside the First Amendment.

We still have a written Constitution, but it is no longer the supreme law of the land. Supremacy now lies in a panel of would-be-Solomons, whose predecessors granted themselves Solomonic power to set aside the Constitution whenever they see fit. This betrayal occurred via the Court's completely gratuitous bit of do-gooding in the Korematsu case. The fabricated federal equal-protection constraint was acknowledged to be overcome by the "compelling state interest" in (instead of by the clear constitutional provision for) letting the executive determine what is and is not a matter of military necessity. For this bit of bit of grandstanding, the Constitution now lies in shreds.

Maybe Cass Sunnstein and Jeffery Rosen did concoct the "Constitution in Exile" moniker out of their own fevered imaginations, but you know what? I like it. Bring that Constitution back out of exile. The place to start is with the carefully calculated dishonesty of Korematsu.

My 2003 Stanford Review article on Korematsu and Bollinger here. Also, some comic relief.

This post slightly edited for clarity, 5/8/05 and 1/6/12.

With the issue of WWII being so greatly-discussed in the Blogosphere, and elsewhere, in very, very recent times, I was just thinking about the Korematsu case a little earlier. I do not know much about the legal aspects of this decision... I am interested in knowing: Do you believe that the case was correctly decided - from a constitutional perspective? (i.e. - Aside from the issue of whether it was right, do you believe that the policy was not unconstitutional, as the Court ruled?)

It's good that you do law-related blogging here... I don't know if I'll end up ever going to law school, but I like to study, learn about, and discuss legal issues and topics.
Definitely correctly decided. The Constitution clearly allows military necessity to take precedence over individual rights and it clearly gives the executive the lead in deciding what is a matter of military necessity. One can argue that habeas corpus can only be constitutionally suspended by Congress, but the Constitution doesn't actually say that. When Lincoln suspended habeus corpus during the Civil War, he did it without consulting Congress, so there is precedent as well.
Nice post. I learn something more difficult on completely different blogs everyday. Thanks for sharing.
I enjoyed reading it. I require to study more on this topic. Thanks for sharing a nice info. Anyway I'm going to subscribe for your feed and I hope you post again soon.
Hey there, You have done a fantastic job. I will certainly digg it and personally suggest to my friends. I am confident they'll be benefited from this website.
Please visit jakarta hotel.
The best site layouts are very pleasing on the eyes, are easy to navigate and provide readers with all of the information that they need to know quickly and simply.

USA Property Investment | SEO Melbourne
I was about to say something on this topic. But now i can see that everything on this topic is very amazing and mind blowing, so i have nothing to say here. I am just going through all the topics and being appreciated. Thanks for sharing..
I really liked this part of the article, with a nice and interesting topics have helped a lot of people who do not challenge things people should know... you need more publicize this so many people who know about it are rare for people to know this, Success for you.
I know where I'm going and I know the truth, and I don't have to be what you want me to be. I'm free to be what I want.Thankyou i really love it



2016 free download latest version








Smadav 2016

firefox 2016

Google Chrome 2016 Offline Installer

Google Chrome 2016 Free Download
You really laid out a great case for yourself. Your point of views were enlightening. bet activate
I really like this concept. Hoping to continue the new ideas with professional excellence. Thanks for sharing.

getmyoffer capitalone com
getipass login

Thanks for sharing informative content, keep sharing quality content.

You can find the perfect customer relationship management software for your business by looking at SalezShark Pennsylvania CRM Software.
Thanks for sharing a great article.
You are providing wonderful information, it is very useful to us.
Keep posting like this informative articles.
Thank you.


joker123 slot
joker123 gaming
slot joker123
joker slot
joker123 online
apk joker123
joker123 apk download
judi slot joker123
user ought to guarantee that the printer head is perfect and liberated from dust. 123.hp.com Residue on the head might cause some block while printing there are two different ways to clear or clean the residue, one being the programmed way and the other the manual one, using the muslin fabric. Doing as such will permit the printer to manage its work proficiently without stalling out. Try not to give too many print occupations to the HP printer consistently; this might cause a error while printing.Always print in ordinary and draft mode from the printer; it will print quicker. Imprinting in higher Dpi or best quality mode will make the HP printer measure a cycle moderate Remove the separators in the records as this will empower the user to try not to print clear pages at the appointed time of distribution from the HP printer.Also, ensure that the rendition of the working framework user is the most recent. In the event that this adaptation is obsolete, the user might confront issues in the arrangement of the wireless HP printer

Cox Email Login is an online login portal that the company provides to its customers enabling them to operate 10 email accounts each capable of 2 GB storage.
cox webmail login |
camps.intuit.com | camps.intuit.com | www.trendmicro.com/activate

How to Set up Microsoft Office with Product Key at office.com/setup
Steps to setup Microsoft Office at microsoft365.com/setup are:
Visit www.office.com/setup and follow the on-screen instructions activation link.
Sign in to your Microsoft account or to manage your Microsoft products’ subscription, create one.
Enter your product key or code and click Next.
When your account successfully associated with the key, you’ll see the page “My Office account“.
Now, Select Install and follow the on-screen instructions.


Your blog gave us significant data to work with. Each and each tip of your post are amazing. You're the best for sharing. Continue to blog





To download the software on your windows pc or hp smart app for mac, you could either first visit the Mac store or Microsoft AppStore and quest for the application OR you can without much of a stretch utilize any of the downloads joins we gave above under the Download and Install header segment to download the application.

This comment has been removed by the author.

The purpose of this article is to demonstrate how you can activate HBO Max on any device and start streaming and broadcasting on it using hbomax com tvsignin.This streaming service bundles all of HBO plus even more TV shows, blockbusters, and new Max Originals in one place for everyone to enjoy.Apple TV users know that HBO Max’s streaming app is subject to frequent crashing and glitches and is often overloaded during important premiere dates. In an overhaul that will continue through next week, the company billed the new app as completely redesigned with some useful new features (although Variety, which earlier reported the news, said the two apps were not too visually dissimilar).On your phone or computer, go to

FREE Rand McNally GPS software Updates?
Rand McNally devices are considered the most user-friendly, easy software-based gps devices. It can update its very easy to use and easy. Rand McNally comes with various gps devices like handheld gps, tablet gps, and in-dash rand McNally. The best part about the rand McNally gps is that every device will update with the same process and software. No matter what rand McNally gps unit you have, they can be updated with the same software. The rand McNally software updater provides updates on an annual basis. It provides three types of updates: Map updates, software updates, and Traffic updates.
The new report by Expert Market Research titled, ‘India Basa Fish Market Report and Forecast 2022-2027’, gives an in-depth analysis of the India Basa Fish Market, assessing the market based on its segments like product types, sources, end uses, and regions. The report tracks the latest trends in the industry and studies their impact on the overall market. It also assesses the market dynamics, covering the key demand and price indicators, along with analysing the market based on the SWOT and Porter’s Five Forces models.
Papers get to operate through Bible helpers and also plagiarism checkers to be certain that the author did not find idle at any stage in the process. Language inconsistencies won't be a thing with your newspapers as the specialists of our school paper writing support are passionate about writing and are always excited to strike you with something fresh. By: 안전놀이터

I have no word to say how many blessings in your provided and posted content. So, I urge to say to continue such posting and provide you with the most sustainable results in terms of your subject matter. So, I want to make an attachment with the International law assignment help for favoring results.

Thanks For sharing such valuable information.

Tamilgun Proxy

A service that produces leads, builds demand, or sets up appointments has emerged from digital marketing. EMarketz is the best lead generation service in india and built a portfolio of unmatched online properties that dominate their respective markets. AI is being used by EMarketz to produce more leads more quickly and with higher quality.

Getting a foster parent and giving back to society may be a awful but generally daunting experience. numerous people need explanation about how to start. UK Fostering is one of the stylish fostering in London.
Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?